Thank you to Library Thing and the publishers for their consideration in sending me this book for review. Sep 03, Dan rated it it was amazing. This is a free book from a LibraryThing author. This 33 page essay was very short, but it says a lot. Back in when the author, Prof. William Graham Sumner, of Yale political Science, wrote this, it told about "The Forgotten Man", the person who falls into the cracks, whenever laws are made.
Laws were made to change the ways of unabiding citizens, while "The Forgotten Man This is a free book from a LibraryThing author.
Laws were made to change the ways of unabiding citizens, while "The Forgotten Man" already obeys the rules and doesn't need a law to persuade him. It also talks about working men and how they contribute to society, unions, and people on welfare. The essay was re-issued because what was said back in , still holds true today. A must read. Jul 16, Danielle rated it liked it. A conservative view of politics of his day that I think, even in his day and more so in the 21st Century, is naive.
His perception of 'Public Policy' is his day as financially empowering "the lazy the shiftless the criminal and the government jobber" at the expense of the ordinary man. Public Policy to develop and foster social and civil development of hospitals libraries nation a series of 11 essays published in in Harper's Weekly, and further developed in two speeches delivered that year.
Public Policy to develop and foster social and civil development of hospitals libraries national parks and more, all at the expense of the ordinary man "the forgotten man". What William Sumner left out was that most of that public policy in some degree or another aided the common ordinary forgotten man and that most of all political policy, public or not, was fostered by elite conservative individuals such as himself. Even though the average worker paid for all this, the forgotten man was appeased by some of that public policy and voted for the Party that pushed it through legislation.
May 21, Ebookwormy1 rated it really liked it Shelves: currenteventspolitics , non-fiction , culture , economics. While Hazlitt's concerns are economic, and many of Sumner's conclusions have economic application, Sumner's scope is broader, and indeed, concerns societal function as a whole. It's amazing that an essay published in still speaks powerfully to the debates present in societal discourse today - even as Sumner's ideas have been pushed far from the mainstream by modern liberals. If you are as captivated as I was, you will want to know this essay was part of a larger publication entitled "What the Social Classes Owe Each Other," that is also available online.
I hope to review that, too. Even if the entire publication is too meaty for you to stomach, I highly recommend "The Forgotten Man" segment and have included a link to the article as well as the brilliant opening and closing paragraphs below, both to remind myself and inspire you to follow!
The radical vice of all these schemes, from a sociological point of view, is that C is not allowed a voice in the matter, and his position, character, and interests, as well as the ultimate effects on society through C's interests, are entirely overlooked. I call C the Forgotten Man The fallacy of all prohibitory, sumptuary, and moral legislation is the same. A and B determine to be teetotalers, which is often a wise determination, and sometimes a necessary one. If A and B are moved by considerations which seem to them good, that is enough. But A and B put their heads together to get a law passed which shall force C to be a teetotaler for the sake of D, who is in danger of drinking too much.
There is no pressure on A and B.
They are having their own way, and they like it. There is rarely any pressure on D. He does not like it, and evades it. The pressure all comes on C. The question then arises, Who is C? He is the man who wants alcoholic liquors for any honest purpose whatsoever, who would use his liberty without abusing it, who would occasion no public question, and trouble nobody at all.
He is the Forgotten Man again, and as soon as he is drawn from his obscurity we see that he is just what each one of us ought to be. Jul 27, Cindy rated it did not like it Recommends it for: no one! Horrible book. Shelves: not-recommended , early-reviewers. The basic idea behind this book is that any form of involvement of the government in social programs of any kind, any type of government regulation of business, is all designed to lead to enslavement.
The 'Forgotten Man' is the one who is the victim of all such legislation. I just can't agree with that assessment. It was impossible for me to read this book without getting angry. There are hundreds of examples that contradict this book.
Online Library of Liberty
According to the author, everyone asking for a handout is eit The basic idea behind this book is that any form of involvement of the government in social programs of any kind, any type of government regulation of business, is all designed to lead to enslavement. According to the author, everyone asking for a handout is either lazy, vicious, or a criminal. Every time someone donates to a charity, he is promoting the welfare of this rotten class of people at the expense of the common working man.
What about organizations like Kiva? I donate and I know where my money is going. What's wrong with helping someone who is struggling? I have been in such a situation, and I do not like the idea that it was all my fault that we were poor because I was either lazy, cruel, or a crook! Or maybe just stupid. Really this is nothing more than propaganda. I very seldom throw books away, but this one is heading for the garbage.
Simply horrible. Jul 23, Jennifer Defoy rated it liked it Shelves: lt-giveaways , reads , gave-away. This book is actually a speech that was given in The concept of this speech is that the lawmakers ask for help for the poor and overlook the class of people that make life in the country possible, the forgotten man.
You are here
There were a few ideas and beliefs that the author talks about in which I don't agree with, but he makes very valid arguments for his ideas. I also did agree with some of what he mentions, however I don't know how feasable his ideas are, and if they would work in the society th This book is actually a speech that was given in I also did agree with some of what he mentions, however I don't know how feasable his ideas are, and if they would work in the society that we live in today.
One thing that surprised me is that even though this speech was written over years ago it was still pertinent to today. I don't know if that is a sign of a great speech writer, to write something that holds true for over years, or if it is a sign that our country really hasn't changed that much in years.
William Graham Sumner: The Forgotten Man Who Reminded Us About 'The Forgotten Man'
It was a quick read, and if nothing else it makes you think about our social and political structure. It was a bit on the rough side to read, because it was pretty dry, but I think more of that was because it was written as a speech rather than a book or a story. I think it was interesting and was worth the hour or so it took me to read it.
Daniel rated it really liked it Jul 02, Bradley Fuller rated it did not like it Feb 14, Boris rated it liked it Aug 13, Maja Leibovitz rated it really liked it Nov 16, Joe Hargrave rated it it was amazing Jul 05, Joshua Gompert rated it it was amazing Jan 03, Smiths rated it liked it Nov 11, Carleton rated it really liked it May 16, Robert rated it it was amazing Apr 11, Fivewincs rated it it was amazing Jun 21, Mike rated it it was amazing Aug 28, Ross rated it it was amazing May 21, Glen Smith rated it it was amazing Jan 27, Carolina Liechtenstein rated it it was amazing Dec 07, Butch Porter rated it it was amazing Jul 11, Kyle Warner rated it really liked it Nov 28, Cara Stefanko rated it liked it Oct 12, Karl Hermann rated it it was amazing Dec 01, Tufts - - Ethics 30 1 The Forgotten Man and Other Essays.
Ethics, by J. Dewey and J. Creative Intelligence, Essays in pragmatic attitude. John Dewey , A. Moore , G. Mead , J. Tufts , H.
- The Forgotten Man: And Other Essays.
- The Night of the Hunter.
- Particle Accelerator Physics!
- Forgotten man - Wikipedia.
- Reprogenetics: Law, Policy, and Ethical Issues.
Sumner: el hombre olvidado. The Thought and Character of William James. Roy Sorensen - - Philosophy 77 1 Introduction: The Forgotten. The New Rationalism, by J. Spaulding - - Ethics Commons - - Ethics The New State, by J. Follett - - Ethics Morals and Politics. Carritt - - Ethics Downloads Sorry, there are not enough data points to plot this chart.
Sign in to use this feature. This article has no associated abstract. No keywords specified fix it.